Update for Cocoa:

The move Cocoa did yesterday constitutes a breakout of an important point on the Cocoa chart (on both a Weekly as well as the Daily chart) - marked with the red arrow. For me, this is a sell signal.
Our position is still in profit by $90, due to the nature of the strategy that we employed. I would take that $90 and get out of the trade. Just close all positions. (
I would do it outside regular trading hours)
The position graph on the left is interesting though. If you think this is a false breakout, just stop running, you would like to give it more time, any move back into the range will quickly realise you some nice profits. And then you have the weekend before you, two more days of time decay, you can easily make $300+ by Monday - IF prices moves back up. A more conservative strategy might be to wait for the open and follow the market closely. Any sign that prices will continue to drop, get out of the trade. You will need to leg out:
drop the loss making ones - May Short Puts, then the Jun Long Call; and then drop the profit making ones - May Short Calls and Jun Long Put - the downwards momentum will ensure you make some additional profits while unwinding the trade. If prices trade back up instead, hold onto the trade, it will quickly give you >$200 and the weekend time decay will see it jump to $300.
HOWEVER - AND THIS IS IMPORTANT: The strategy described above requires you to be online and in front of your computer when the Cocoa market opens, and to be watching the action unfold during the live trading session - and then to make some quick decisions. My personal trading style see me only monitoring the markets on a daily basis, I do not follow the live trading sessions. On my daily watch, this is a sell signal, the risk is too high, so I just get out..